The resilience of New York soars sky-high – The Tribune India

Follow Us

Login   /  Register

A +

It is reassuring to see New York’s skyline delineated by WTC-1 after 9/11. Along with it have come more additions, forming a grander and bigger vision. New York epitomises the land of opportunities, fortunes, enterprise and talent to reach for the sky. For millions of escapees of repression — as the Afghan crisis has shown — it is the promised land, emblematic of the free world.
A +
Updated At: Sep 11, 2021 05:24 AM (IST)
SYMBOLIC: After 9/11, New York resolved to build a grander WTC. Photo by the author
Rajnish Wattas
Former Principal, Chandigarh College of Architecture

EDWARD Glaeser, eminent Harvard professor, in his 2011 seminal book Triumph of the City, serenaded New York and other global cities as “engines of growth” that propelled global economies. He argued that they brought together hugely talented people in close proximity and that generated greater productivity, innovation and enterprise. The glitz of closely-knit skyscrapers, denoting symbols of “strength” and “power of modern times” seduced high achievers.
However, this September 11, marking two decades of the 9/11 terror attacks in the heart of New York that killed nearly 3,000 people, will be a grim reminder of the fragility of such certainties of sky-soaring urbanism and dizzying assumptions of success.
Twenty years ago on this day, its legendary Twin Towers of the World Trade Center were reduced to rubble, leaving a gaping hole, ‘Ground Zero’, at the site. To rebuild and resurrect the demolished American spirit, New York resolved to build an even taller and grander World Trade Center, putting in the best of hallmark American might and entrepreneurial spirit.
The new and more ambitious programme for the site included not only the new World Trade Center, called WTC-1, but also five skyscrapers (1, 2, 3, 4 and 5 WTC), the National September 11 Memorial & Museum, a transportation hub and a performing arts centre.
With most of these key components now completed and inaugurated, the project symbolises a unique and unprecedented teamwork of international architects, artists and urban developers, their common objective being “the creation of a grand, inspiring new urban centre for 21st century New York.”
But clearly, the key defining project of this ensemble is the 104-storey WTC-1 — originally called the Freedom Tower — designed by architect David M Childs. It stands at a symbolic 1,776 feet, signifying the year America signed the Declaration of Independence. Amidst New York’s awesome skyline of iconic buildings, like the Empire State, Chrysler Building and many more in such eclectic classical, neo-classical styles, the newly erected glossy facade fills the void of the original World Trade Center reassuringly.
Notwithstanding such resilience and American muscle, the post-pandemic world, buffeted by climate change-induced devastating hurricanes, begs the question: are dense, vertical mega cities like New York relevant anymore? The pandemic saw many big corporate houses letting go of their huge expensive office spaces, with work-from-home models working reasonably well. Similarly, many upper crust executives moved from their high rental apartments in crowded Manhattan to greener and larger homes in the satellite towns. Even with the pandemic abating, the hybrid model of partial work from home is here to stay. It saves offices’ expensive real estate and, for employees, assures better quality of family life.
Not surprisingly, therefore, notwithstanding the recent catastrophes, the ‘Big Apple’ is gradually regaining its economic and cultural pulse. Its enigmatic laissez faire skyline is filling up yet again, with a warm, intimate and vibrant life on the streets.
Manhattan is the financial and cultural centre of the US and one of top financial capitals of the world, with an estimated GDP of over $1.2 trillion before the pandemic. It is home to the famous Wall Street, inspiring many blockbuster Hollywood films and international cinema. With the recent trend of businesses opening up, its famous adrenaline-charged bankers, stock brokers and investment experts will once again strut about briskly in their dark suits. Amidst this human carnival of racing, hurried people —eating, texting, chatting on their cellphones — one would still be hearing gentle peals of church bells from some old stone cathedral nearby, sandwiched between towering blocks, thankfully saved by New York’s heritage laws.
The Manhattan model of verticality has always evoked strong views, both admiration and scathing criticism.
Lewis Mumford, 20th century’s critic, historian and city planner, has said, “New York is the perfect model of city, not the model of a perfect city.” Le Corbusier, Chandigarh’s iconic architect-planner, when he first arrived in New York in 1935, awed by the dreamy spires of the high-rises soaring up in the sky, famously described it as “the Grand Canyon of concrete and steel.” However, his views changed after rejections from American tycoons as they turned down his proposal for restructuring the Manhattan grid with his own ideal of a vertical green. And, many may not be aware of his role in the designing of the UN building, albeit full of disappointing recriminations, too. Iconic contemporary architect and urbanist Rem Kool has countered, saying that the grid’s two-dimensional form created an “undreamed of freedom for three-dimensional anarchy.”
Whatever be the opinions about New York, it is reassuring to see its vertical skyline delineated by WTC-1 after 9/11. Along with it have come more additions, forming a grander and bigger vision. New York epitomises the land of opportunities, fortunes, enterprise and talent to reach for the sky. For millions of escapees of repression — as the recent Afghan crisis has shown — it is the promised land, emblematic of the free world.
The words at the base of the Statue of Liberty by Emma Lazarus, “Give me your tired, your poor, your huddled masses yearning to breathe free…,” still ring true for all immigrants seeking refuge and shelter.
Tribune Shorts
A +
What do you think? (Share your feedback)
Most Read
Don’t Miss
Was Pegasus used illegally, asks SC after Centre refuses to file additional affidavit
Says will pass interim order on pleas seeking court-monitore…
WHO nod likely for Covaxin this week
PM scheduled to visit US later this month
Wary of direct aid to Afghan, India pitches for UN role
Taliban dismiss rumours of Dy PM Baradar’s death
Stir hurting Punjab economy: Capt Amarinder Singh to farmers
Asks them to shift protest to Delhi borders
Punjab Chief Minister fears poll losses, claim SKM leaders
Haryana Home Minister Anil Vij flays Captain
View All
With minimal staff, clinical work takes a hit at dental college in Amritsar

Heritage tampered with, says Laxmi Kanta Chawla at Jallianwala Bagh; MP Shwait Malik differs

Drone spotted; two boxes seized in Amritsar

Jalandhar BJP legal cell chief held in Amritsar

Days after ‘cracking’ case, family alleges police inaction

Antibodies in 50% Bathinda kids: Survey

Health Secretary’s night visit catches hospital staff on the wrong foot in Chandigarh

Zirakpur: It’s diarrhoea, confirms Civil Surgeon

Look into multi-level parking issues, Chandigarh Adviser asks Anindita Mitra

Chandigarh traffic police replaces accused with violators in TVIS

Covid-19: Chandigarh sees six cases, no death

Delhi: 2 children dead as building collapses in Sabzi Mandi area

Kejriwal elected AAP convener for third time

CISF nabs 3 with fake Indian passports at Delhi airport

Urge Centre to direct states to mandatorily use Pusa bio-decomposer for stubble management: Kejriwal

Crowds at Singhu, Tikri thinning as protesting farmers head home ahead of harvesting season

Jalandhar BJP legal cell chief held in Amritsar

No end to commuters’ woes in Jalandhar

Youth Akali Dal, shopkeepers block road over not razing unsafe buildings in Kapurthala

Krishan Nagar residents irked over shoddy work by civic body

Covid-19: 4 more test positive, no death in Jalandhar district

Suspected rabid dog bites 11 in Ludhiana city areas

66% kids in Ludhiana district have developed antibodies to Covid, says survey

At 1,280, Ludhiana sees max accidents

2 bikes stolen; house, shop burgled in Ludhiana

One dead, 4 test positive for Covid in Ludhiana district

2 ETT-qualified youths jump into Bhakra Canal

Rs 25-cr sop for industry to curb farm fires in Punjab

Robotics consultant launches lab for youngsters in Patiala

At 1,280, Ludhiana sees max accidents

Row over allocation of land for Verka booth in Patiala

The Tribune, now published from Chandigarh, started publication on February 2, 1881, in Lahore (now in Pakistan). It was started by Sardar Dyal Singh Majithia, a public-spirited philanthropist, and is run by a trust comprising four eminent persons as trustees.
The Tribune, the largest selling English daily in North India, publishes news and views without any bias or prejudice of any kind. Restraint and moderation, rather than agitational language and partisanship, are the hallmarks of the paper. It is an independent newspaper in the real sense of the term.
The Tribune has two sister publications, Punjabi Tribune (in Punjabi) and Dainik Tribune (in Hindi).
Remembering Sardar Dyal Singh Majithia
Designed and Developed by: Grazitti Interactive